Our Companies

Claim Number: 800-375-2075

Claim Number: 800-231-2318

Claim Number: 877-445-5780

Since 2010 Goodville Mutual, based in New Holland, Pennsylvania, has been recognized by the Ward Group as one of the top 50 performing property and casualty insurance companies in the nation. Our mission is to provide comprehensive property and casualty insurance products of the highest quality and to conduct our business by biblical principles of love, justice and integrity. We are committed to maintaining lasting relationships with policyholders, independent agents and employees; giving excellent customer service; promoting safety and loss prevention; and contributing a portion of our operating profits to charitable organizations.

Claim Number: 800-445-3030

Grange Insurance was first formed 80 years ago to provide affordable car insurance for a specific group—grange members (known nationally as the National Grange Patrons of the Husbandry). But even in the company’s earliest days, its leaders were thinking ahead to the future. Today, we offer affordable and customizable auto, home, life and business insurance products. Together with Integrity Insurance, our affiliate company, we continue to sell exclusively through independent agents and serve customers across 13 states: Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia and Wisconsin. Financial strength is one of the most important things to consider when choosing a carrier. With an “A” rating from A.M. Best and $3 billion in assets, Grange has the strength and stability of a large insurance carrier but with the local, personalized service of a small company.

Claims: Contact Agent

We know there are other options out there. But no one knows classic cars and their owners better than Hagerty. We know how you treat your classic, what it means to you, and the lengths you’ll go to protect it. So we created classic car insurance and other great resources just for drivers like you — people who love classics as much as we do.

Claims Number: 800-442-8277

Claim Number: 844-225-2467

Claim Number: 800-686-3011

Based in Bucyrus, Ohio, Ohio Mutual Insurance Group writes more than $220 million in premiums each year – covering homes, autos, farms, and commercial properties in seven states. We maintain the prestigious “A” Excellent rating from A.M. Best, and were named in 2009 – 2013 among the top 50 insurers in the country by Ward Group – recognizing our outstanding operating performance, capitalization, underwriting expertise, and prudent investment strategy.

Claim Number: 800-776-4737

Claim Number: 800-332-3226

Claims: Contact Agent

For more than a century, the Wayne Insurance Group companies have delivered financial security and peace of mind for families, farms and businesses. As mutual insurance companies, we exist to serve the insurance needs of our policyholders.  We have partnered with a network of independent agents to offer a full line of insurance programs backed by prompt, fair claims service and support. Founded in 1910, Wayne Mutual Insurance Company’s mission is to provide quality insurance protection and service to our policyholders. Wayne Mutual offers a full line of personal, farm and commercial insurance products.

Claims Number: 1-800-362-0426

Claim Number: 800-243-0210

Website: wyandotmutual.com